by Martha Heineman Pieper,
Ph.D. and William Joseph Pieper, M.D.
The Compassionate Alternative to Discipline That Will
Make You a Better Parent and Your Child a Better Person
What Is Smart Love?
9 Principles of Smart Love
- A Child Is a Child
Learn to see the world through your child's eyes.
Give up the illusion that your child is a miniature
adult. You promote a child's growth better by
embracing immaturity than by fighting it.
- Foster Optimism
A child brings loads of hope and good cheer into
this world. Teach your child to look life's
obstacles squarely in the eye, but never, ever scare
your child into becoming a pessimist.
- Cultivate Inner Happiness
The greatest gift you can give your child is a
sturdy fortress of inner happiness. Outward
happiness always will be fleeting and uncertain
without this inward foundation.
- You Are Your Child's Ideal
If you come across as perpetually unhappy with your
child, always acting tough and talking negatively,
then your child will expect and want that
unhappiness--and will do whatever it takes to get
more of it. Do not teach your child to seek
unhappiness.
- Happy Children Behave
Parenting is not "behavior modification."
Cultivating your child's inner happiness is what
really leads to good behavior. Chances are your
child will behave better if you spend less time
trying to change his or her behavior.
- Provide Quantity Time
On one side are all the reasons you do not have any
to give. On the other are the great rewards you and
your child will reap when you manage to do so. Make
the effort. Quality Time does not make up for a lack
of Quantity Time.
- Attention Breeds
Independence
Lots of loving attention will make your child
independent. Let go of those worries that you will
spoil your child, or make your child needy and
dependent, by providing too much attention.
- Capture the Middle Ground
No parent should feel stuck between being a pushover
and a disciplinarian, between letting everything go
and relying on the "quick fix" of discipline. You
can find a happy medium.
- Use Your Head and Trust
Your Heart
Always remember: Your parenting instincts are good
ones. If your head tells you that tough discipline
is necessary, but your heart is not in it, take
heed. The foremost expert on parenting is the one
you see in the mirror.
A Surefire Recipe for Successful Parenting
All parents want to raise a happy, successful child,
but there is little agreement about how best to reach
this goal. Over the years, parents have tried
dramatically different recipes. They have put their baby
on a schedule, or they have fed on demand; they have let
their baby cry herself to sleep, or they have picked her
up as soon as she cried; they have stayed home with
their child, or they have entrusted her to day care and
gone to work; they have taught their baby letters and
numbers, or they have left her mind a clean slate for
her teachers to write on; they have given their child
whatever she wants, or they have made her earn what she
gets; they have made their child do chores, or they have
asked little of her around the house; they have demanded
good grades, or they have let their child find her own
level in school.
These contrasting parenting strategies arise from quite
different views of the nature of children and childhood
and the roles of parents. Some parents view their child
as naturally social and their job as allowing her the
space to thrive, while others think that their child is
by nature out of control. Some parents are convinced
that their child is morally innocent, while others
believe she is wily and manipulative. Some parents see
their child as inclined to be dependent and needing help
to leave the nest, while others are convinced their
child needs constant attention and guidance.
Whether you are the parent of a newborn or an
adolescent, the parent of one child or five you may
worry about making the correct response to your child
when she cries, makes demands, is frightened, wants
constant cuddling and other attention, or won't do what
is good for her (for example, she refuses to eat her
vegetables, go to sleep, do her homework, or come in at
curfew).
As parents and as mental health professionals we have
lived and struggled with these same fundamental issues.
The discoveries we made in the course of decades of
researching the subject of the true nature of the child,
as well as the question of the necessary ingredients for
a child's healthy emotional development, have given us a
new understanding of children and childhood, which, in
turn, led us to create guidelines that all parents can
use to parent lovingly but knowledgeably and
effectively. Hence the term smart love.
In the first three chapters, we lay out the basic
principles of the smart love approach to parenting--for
example, that it is important to see the world and,
especially, yourself, through your child's eyes; that
sometimes it is best to accept your child's emotional
immaturity, even when it is played out in behaviors like
cheating at games or not wanting to share toys; that
parents are not stuck with a choice between soft
permissiveness and hard discipline because smart love
makes possible an effective middle ground, called loving
regulation; that children who are treated harshly come
not only to expect unhappiness but to want it; that you
cannot spoil your child with positive attention and, in
fact, that lots of loving attention will make your child
independent, not dependent; that quantity time is as
important as quality time; that tantrums, nightmares,
night terrors, habitual sibling quarrels, and many other
conspicuous displays of childhood unhappiness are not
inevitable; and that the best parenting involves using
your head while trusting your heart.
In the later chapters, we focus on the developmental
milestones from infancy through adolescence so that you
will know for sure what behaviors are appropriate at
what age. When your child's behavior needs regulation,
we will show you why it is less important to wonder "How
do I get Jill to behave herself right now?" than to ask
yourself, "How can I help Jill develop into an adult who
will want to, and be able to, take good care of herself
and be caring toward others when I am not around?"
We return to the question Socrates asked almost
twenty-five hundred years ago, "Can virtue be taught,
and if so, how?" All parents face the question of the
best way to help their child acquire a reliable capacity
for self-regulation. What history has taught us is that
we cannot rely on the four most common methods of trying
to teach children self-discipline--moral instruction,
disciplinary measures, permissiveness, and rewards. We
will show you another way to think about guiding your
child toward responsible adulthood. Loving regulation is
a means of protecting children from the consequences of
their immaturity while at the same time offering them
your ongoing love and admiration. When you help your
child make constructive choices in a context of an
ongoing close relationship, your child will come to
recognize that the deepest happiness results from loving
and feeling lovable and loved rather than from
satisfying particular desires or achieving specific
goals. Your child will learn to govern herself better
through the desire to feel happier and more competent
than she ever would from fear of negative consequences.
You will learn how best to satisfy your child's
developmental needs and how to use loving regulation to
manage her immature behaviors. With the guidelines we
provide, you can help your child to acquire a stable
inner well-being that is unaffected by success, failure,
or other ups and downs of daily life, and that will
enable your child to reach her full potential.
Smart Love Just Makes Sense
You will benefit from this book if:
- you want to help your child reach her full
potential and grow up to be a happy, loving adult;
- you want to understand childhood from your
child's point of view;
- you want to improve and strengthen your
relationship with your child;
- you are uncomfortable with the disciplinary
measures advocated by most popular books but worry
that offering children too much love and affection
will "spoil" them;
- you aren't sure how to regulate your child's
behavior without stifling her spirit;
- you are a busy working parent and want to ensure
that you spend a maximum amount of pleasurable and
meaningful time with your child;
- your child is unhappy (difficult, moody, or has
nervous habits, trouble sleeping, school problems,
trouble maintaining positive relationships); or
- you aren't actively parenting at the moment, but
you work with children and/or you are interested in
understanding why some children grow up happy and
fulfilled while others become unhappy and difficult.
As parents ourselves, we have experienced firsthand
the joys and the demands of parenthood. And because of
our therapeutic efforts with hundreds of families from
differing socio-economic, racial, ethnic, and cultural
backgrounds, we also know that smart love guidelines are
equally useful with all children and can be applied by
any parent. The case examples we use throughout this
book to illustrate the principles of smart love are all
real-life instances of parents putting smart love into
action.
Until now, smart love has been used and appreciated only
by our clients and in academic and clinical settings.
This book is the fruit of our long-standing wish to
present smart love to a wide readership so that all
parents will have the tools they need to raise happy,
fulfilled, loving children.
The Basics of Smart Love
No matter what your child's age, with the help of
smart love principles you can implement more effective
and compassionate parenting strategies. Smart love gives
you a relaxed and realistic timetable for your child's
emotional development; identifies heretofore
unrecognized developmental milestones and shows you how
to help your child reach them; offers you a way to
protect your child from missteps caused by her
immaturity without resorting to the extremes of
permissiveness or strict disciplinary measures (both of
which are counterproductive); and makes it possible for
you to raise a successful and truly happy child. Just as
important, if your child is unhappy and difficult, the
smart love principles will show you how to recapture her
birthright of inner happiness.
Smart love offers a new understanding of the entire
sweep of child development, allowing you to view the
process of growing up through your child's eyes. With an
awareness of how your child's experience of the
parent-child relationship changes as she grows from
infancy through adolescence, you will be better able to
provide your child with a lasting conviction that she is
loved and understood.
By reading this book, you will have a better
understanding of your baby's cries, and why your
two-year-old's favorite word is "no." You will discover
why four-year-olds refuse to believe there is anything
they cannot do by themselves, and you will learn that
the best way to motivate children to do chores and
homework is also the kindest and most gradual. With the
help of smart love guidelines it will be possible for
both you and your child to enjoy your child's
adolescence.
We would like to mention here that although in these
pages we sometimes assume the presence of two
heterosexual parents, smart love methods are equally
useful in any family arrangement. We wrote this book to
help all parents, and we do not mean for any parent to
feel excluded or overlooked.
Your Child's Inner Happiness
The fundamental viewpoint that informs our approach
concerns your child's outlook at birth. Contrary to
conventional wisdom, your newborn is not an
undifferentiated blob who is aware only of himself.
Instead, our research indicates that when your baby
meets you he is an optimist with regard to human
relationships. Unlike adults, infants are absolutely
certain that whatever happens to them is for the best,
because their beloved parents have caused or intended
whatever happens. Your brand-new baby believes both that
he is engaging your love, and also that the care he
receives is ideal. When these inborn convictions are
confirmed day after day, your child grows up to possess
a lasting inner happiness. As we will describe, this
unshakable inner happiness, in turn, will allow him to
attain his highest potential.
Primary Happiness
Primary happiness originates in the conviction that
all infants bring into the world that they are causing
their parents, whom they adore more than life itself, to
pay loving attention to their developmental needs. Your
child's primary happiness becomes unshakable when he is
certain that you love caring for him. As he matures,
your child will increasingly use the knowledge that you
are helping him to become happy and competent as the
source of his primary happiness. Once his primary
happiness is firmly in place, your child's day-to-day
happiness will no longer depend on whether or not you
are able to respond to any one particular need at a
given moment.
We have found that children can acquire primary
happiness that will not alter with life's ups and downs,
and that this is the child's most important
developmental achievement. Even though you may have been
told that "healthy" doses of frustration build
character, it is your caring responses that instill
stable primary happiness in your child. As you will see,
unnecessary frustration and deprivation actually
interfere with your child's acquisition of stable
primary happiness by causing him to develop needs to
make himself unhappy.
Secondary Happiness
While primary happiness is generated within your
child's relationship with you, secondary happiness is
the pleasure generated by everyday activities (such as
building with blocks, dressing a doll, solving a math
problem, playing the violin, hitting a baseball). The
process of developing stable secondary happiness begins
in your child's second year and is completed only at the
end of adolescence. With the same smart love guidelines
you use to foster your child's unshakable primary
happiness, you can help your child develop permanent
secondary happiness.
In his first year, your baby uses the satisfaction
generated by intellectual, social, and physical pursuits
to supply himself with primary happiness. Being fed
sustains your infant's primary happiness because it
strengthens his belief that he is causing you to love
caring for him. When you give food to your hungry
preschooler, his primary happiness is nourished by your
responsiveness and, in addition, he gains secondary
happiness in the process of helping with food
preparation (stirring,, mixing, and pouring).
As with primary happiness, secondary happiness follows a
developmental course. Initially secondary happiness is
unreliable because it depends entirely on your child's
ability to attain whatever satisfactions his heart
desires. By the end of adolescence, however, your
child's secondary happiness can become as stable as his
primary happiness because he recognizes that making
constructive choices and pursuing them well is more
reliably satisfying than getting what he wants when he
wants it. Stable secondary happiness is linked to the
enjoyment of activities and pursuits, but because it is
not outcome-dependent it is not shaken by the occasional
setbacks or frustrations that are bound to occur.
The All-Powerful Self and the Competent Self
In the early years, your child's secondary happiness
is bundled with her conviction that she is so powerful
that she can do and have anything. This belief, made
possible by your child's cognitive immaturity, is one of
the main reasons that she will be vulnerable to
self-caused physical injury. If left unattended, your
young child might, for example, decide to turn on the
stove to cook, to drive the family car, to swim in the
pool, or to plug in a hair dryer without the slightest
inkling that she might not be fully capable of handling
these activities.
Why Children Become Unhappy and Difficult
Contrary to popular belief, inborn temperament is not
the reason that children become unhappy and develop
problematic behavior. Through our extensive clinical
experience we have come to the conclusion that children
become unhappy because they have learned to desire
unhappiness, which happens when they are regularly made
to feel unhappy or their unhappiness is not responded
to.
As we have said, all babies meet their parents as
optimists with regard to relationships. Each infant
believes that his parents are perfect caregivers who are
perfectly devoted to him. He has an inborn conviction
that everything that happens to him is for the best
because it is intended and approved by his parents. As a
result, we believe, when for some reason parents are
consistently unable to satisfy a child's developmental
needs, the infant reacts by believing that his unhappy
or alienated feelings are intended and approved of by
his parents. Out of love for their parents, and in an
attempt to care for themselves exactly as their beloved
parents care for them, such children unknowingly develop
the desire to cause themselves exactly the same
discomfort they believe their parents want for them.
These children believe that they are seeking happiness
when they strive to recreate the feelings they
experienced in their parents' presence.
This learned but unrecognized need to experience
unhappiness explains why so many children (and adults)
react to success with depression or self-defeating
actions. Children who have acquired needs to make
themselves unhappy may show symptoms such as frequent
temper tantrums, depression, difficulties concentrating,
low self-esteem, and problems with drugs and alcohol.
The good news is that it is never too late to help
unhappy and difficult children. Smart love guidelines
help parents help their children to change in positive,
lasting ways. By learning how to build on their
children's inborn, enduring desires to have a positive
and loving relationship with their parents, all parents
can make significant and constructive changes in their
parenting and thereby ease the misery of problem
children of any age.
Avoid Denting Your Child’s Primary Happiness
You want to avoid causing your child to feel ashamed,
bad, or as though you don't want her around when she is
angry or upset. Parents are frequently advised to tell
their child that her behavior makes them angry. But
children cannot distinguish between their parents' anger
at their behavior and their parents' feelings about
them. This is true even of adolescents, who possess the
intellectual maturity to understand the distinction
their parents are making, but feel hurt nonetheless.
When children repeatedly experience their parents as
being angry at them, they copy their parents and develop
needs to feel angry at themselves. If a child has
already acquired inner unhappiness, the experience that
her parents are angry with her will strengthen her needs
to cause herself unhappiness.
A variation on this approach is the commonly heard
advice that parents should tell their child that, while
they don't like her behavior, they still love her ("I am
unhappy when you..."). Even this is too negative. What
children hear at such a moment is that their parents are
disappointed in them. Instead you need to focus on
regulating the action that is dangerous or
inappropriate. It is enough simply to say, "Please don't
pound with the hammer on the table. I'll go get your
pounding board." If the child doesn't respond, the
matter-of-fact statement "If you don't stop, I'll have
to take the hammer away for a while" is strong enough.
If you have to take the hammer away from her, try to
maintain a positive and friendly manner ("I have to put
the hammer away for now, but we can bang spoons on this
pot"). Your child will realize that the hammer may have
to go, but your love and caring remain.
Understanding Your Anger
Even though you will feel angry with your child at
times, there is all the difference in the world between
believing that your anger is justified (with the result
that you reinforce your child's belief that he Is
responsible for it) and realizing that anger does not
further the goal of giving your child lasting inner
happiness and an abiding sense of competence. It is not
uncommon for parents to become angry when their child
gives them a bad scare. But once you understand that
anger makes you less effective as a parent, you will be
motivated to hold your anger, thereby relieving your
child of the burden of your irate feelings. For example,
if you become outwardly furious with your young child
who has run dangerously close to the street, feel free
to give him an immediate hug and say, "I'm sorry I
yelled, honey. You didn't do anything bad--it is my job
to make sure you don't go near the street until you are
old enough to realize that cars can really hurt you.
Let's go back to the playground and swing."
Parents also tend to become angry when their child
behaves in a way that is appropriate for his age, but
the parent is judging the child's behavior based on what
would be unacceptable in an adult. A teen may complain
about having to do chores or absentmindedly leave the
refrigerator door open, defrosting all the frozen goods.
Parents may become angry if they conclude based on this
behavior that their teen has become permanently selfish,
irresponsible, and disobedient. They would find it
easier to dispel or moderate their angry feelings and
respond constructively to their teenager if they kept in
mind that the developmental pushes and pulls of
adolescence typically, though temporarily, make teens
forgetful and resistant.
Your Crying Infant Is Not Manipulating You
We cannot overemphasize that your crying infant is
not trying to manipulate you, and that responding
lovingly will build rather than corrupt his character.
Manipulation is a word that never applies to babies.
Crying is the child's way of expressing misery at
feeling both overwhelmed and also incapable of eliciting
your loving assistance. Crying is not a calculated act.
Anger or withdrawal on your part convinces the child
that he is unattractive to you (and, therefore, to
himself) when he is unhappy. The child whose tears evoke
parents anger or seeming indifference grows into the
adult who compounds everyday sadness and disappointment
by feeling unlovable when he is unhappy. Remember that
you are the source of your young child's greatest
happiness. If you freely supply your loving attention,
your child gains a storehouse of well-being that will
last a lifetime and see him through every disappointment
and frustration.
Parents can usually find ways of soothing their infant
when daily care causes distress. For example, bathing a
newborn can be upsetting for the child. Many infants do
not like the feeling of being lowered naked into water.
The smart love principle is to try to keep your baby as
happy as possible. There is no reason to give your baby
a true bath until he is old enough to enjoy it.
Premoisturized cleansing tissues or a well-wrung
washcloth applied to face and bottom will provide
acceptable hygiene without upsetting your baby
unnecessarily.
You Can't Spoil Your Child with the Right Kind of
Attention
You may have been warned that the constant
gratification of your child's desires for your attention
will make him unfit for the real world, the reality is
that your child's intense desires for focused parenting
will be temporary if you are consistently able to
respond positively to him. Gratifying your child's
wishes, especially his desires to engage your focused
attention, will not spoil your child. It will not make
him hopelessly self-centered or unable to postpone
gratification. In fact, your child's all-encompassing
need for your focused attention will decrease when he
becomes certain of your unconditional wish to respond to
his needs and provide the attention he wants.
In contrast, if you ration your attention out of concern
that too much is harmful, your child will never feel
fully certain of his ability to elicit the caregetting
pleasure he wants and needs. When children find that
they cannot count on their parents to respond to their
needs, they initially react by intensifying their
demands for parental involvement. If these demands are
not responded to, children may even turn away from the
ungratifying relationship and disavow their wishes for
closeness.
If you try to gratify your child's needs and wishes
whenever possible, you will help your child to acquire a
lifelong sense of competence and inner well-being. This
unshakable inner happiness, in turn, will allow your
child to become good, to do good, and to do well. For
this reason, on a temporary basis, try to give your
child's wishes priority, provided these desires are safe
and do not conflict with your essential personal aims
(stopping for gas, putting away frozen foods).
By fulfilling your child's developmental needs and
wishes you will not spoil your child. You will be giving
him the tools to become a happy, competent, and socially
engaged adult. Your smart love assures your child that
he is causing you to love caring for him, and this
certainty, in turn, provides him with a well-being rich
enough to share with others.
How to Help Your Child Adjust to School Rules
Once in school, your child's customary freedom of
choice is suddenly reined in by demands that she walk in
a line, wait to talk, take turns playing with the most
desirable toys, forgo eating her snack until everyone
else is served, and ask permission to use the bathroom.
Because your preschooler views much of the world through
the unrealistic lens of her all-powerful self, she may
well experience the multitude of school rules and
regulations as oppressive and, more significantly, as
applying to other children but not to her.
If your child resists classroom socializing, this does
not mean that you should have been tougher on her; this
reaction serves to emphasize the importance of her years
of relative freedom. If you have consistently encouraged
and facilitated your child's wish to make choices for
herself, she actually will adapt more easily to the
school's imposition of structure, because she will not
enter school with a broken spirit or locked in a chronic
battle with authority. Your child will soon realize that
a few irritating rules and regulations are a small price
to pay for the opportunities to engage in the exciting
activities and satisfying social relationships that
school can offer.
You can facilitate your child's transition to school
in a number of ways:
- You can say something like "I know it's
difficult not being able to eat anytime you want,
the way you can at home, but, on the other hand, at
school the paints are always out, and there is a
water table and three hamsters! "
- When your child chafes at school rules, you can
help by giving her as much latitude as possible
after school. This is not the time to schedule
ballet lessons or other structured activities.
- If your child is especially tired, grouchy, or
fragile in the first weeks of school, try to
remember that your child is experiencing emotional
overload, and you may find it easier to be
affectionate and understanding.
When Schoolmates Hurt Your Child's Feelings
Unless your child has already encountered rebuffs
from older siblings or neighbors, in the beginning she
may return from school with her feelings bruised by the
rough-and-tumble of peer relations. The child who knows
that you love her and love being with her may be amazed
and upset when other children exclude her or become
angry with her. Because the child's all-powerful self
believes in its power to control other people, a child
of this age feels especially wounded by a friend's
refusal to play. You will feel for your child when she
says plaintively, "Jenny didn't want to play with me
today. She said she will never play with me again." Yet
these moments provide golden opportunities to help your
child to draw on the reservoir of love and trust she has
accumulated with you, to supply herself with secondary
happiness in the face of the disappointments that result
from others' conflicting motives.
You can sometimes help your child by emphasizing the
difference between her relationship with you and her
friendships. You might say, "It may feel confusing and
hurtful because we always like to play with you and
here's someone saying she doesn't want to. But sometimes
other children don't do what you want. When that
happens, it's better to try to find a friend who feels
like playing. I am sure that there is someone in your
class who would be delighted to play with you. I
remember you said you had fun with Samantha." Over time,
because of your help and caring, your child will come to
derive greater secondary happiness from the fun of
playing than from the illusion that she can convince
each and every child to play with her at all times.
Occasionally children will report that classmates have
made cruel remarks to them. We know one little boy who
reported to his mother that there was a girl he liked at
school, and he had told her he wanted to marry her. She
replied, "I can never marry you, your skin is too dark."
Parents should acknowledge that the cutting remark must
have really hurt. They can also emphasize that the other
child was mistaken, saying, for example, "I know what
she said hurt your feelings. But what she said is wrong;
no skin color is better than any other, and people can
marry whomever they please." Parents' opinions are more
important than peers' judgments at this age. If you
emphatically disagree with the other child's put-down,
your child will listen.
It is sometimes difficult to know whether to take action
outside the family when your child has been insulted. In
general, run-of-the-mill insults, such as comments about
your child's clothes, weight, or glasses, are best dealt
with at home. But if there is a pattern of racial,
religious, or ethnic slurs, or your child is being
teased because she has a significant disability, you
might suggest to the teacher that a classroom discussion
of differences in skin color or religious and cultural
practices, or of the feelings of people with
disabilities, might be in order.
How to Help Your Child with Homework
In trying to help your child with homework, use the
same approach as when you taught her to tie her shoes or
to ride a bike. Foster your child's efforts by making
concrete assistance available in a relaxed way and with
ongoing love and affection. Parents often worry about
the extent to which they should supervise and assist
their children with homework. Fortunately, the child who
possesses a durable inner happiness will most likely
resolve this dilemma for you. Because she enjoys using
her own mind, your child will neither hesitate to ask
for help when she needs it, nor seek help when she
doesn't. Still, in the earlier grades children may need
an occasional reminder to get to their homework.
The most effective assistance you can offer your child
with her homework assignments is to establish a daily
work time before or after dinner. You can use this time
to sit down and read, knit, do crossword puzzles, pay
bills, write letters, or do other desk work. Your child
will feel proud and grown-up to be doing her work right
alongside Mom, Dad, big sister, or big brother. Try to
avoid pursuing distracting activities, such as watching
TV or playing video games, during prime homework times.
It is crucial that you view your efforts to help your
child with her homework as purely facilitative. Your aim
is to advance your child's abilities to derive secondary
happiness from making constructive choices and becoming
proficient in her efforts (for example, to help her to
learn how to organize, schedule, and complete homework),
rather than to make certain that any particular homework
assignment gets done or is done to some established
level.
If a child asks for help with a homework problem or
project, feel free to offer it, secure in the knowledge
that the child wants to feel and to be competent. The
more you can respond positively ("I'd be delighted to
help you. Let's try this problem together.") and show
the child how to think through and analyze a question,
the more effectively the child will navigate the
important balance between sticking with a difficult task
and appropriately asking for help when she needs it.
Don't Stand By and Watch Teens Fail
Many experts recommend that parents let their
children and adolescents experience the "natural
consequences" of their immaturity or willfulness. The
smart love perspective is that when you stand by and let
bad things happen, your child experiences the twin
disappointments that something went wrong and that you
did not seem to care enough about her to lift a finger
to help prevent the mishap. The "natural consequences"
approach is really a form of punishment. Children are
never fooled into thinking that you had nothing to do
with the unpleasant outcome.
A common situation in which parents might be advised to
let "natural consequences" teach teens a lesson involves
teenagers' difficulties getting out of bed on school
days. Parents are often told to let their adolescent
experience the results of her tardiness, such as
detention, a lowered grade, or extra work. What they
don't realize is that their child will believe that her
parents are letting her down out of indifference or
dislike. A more effective approach is to have a
discussion with your teen the night before about the
difficulty of waking her up. You can ask your adolescent
to suggest effective methods to help her get going. One
teen we know decided that the only arrangement certain
to arouse her would be a cold washcloth placed on her
face, and, in fact, this proved an effective wake-up
call. If, despite your best efforts, you cannot wake
your child, you can at least spare her the
disappointment that you knowingly let her harm herself.
Parents sometimes say, "But she is practically an adult.
If I keep performing these basic functions for her, how
will she ever learn to take care of herself?" The smart
love response is that, just as she needed you to get
milk for her when she was a hungry six-month-old, she
needs you now. We cannot overemphasize that adolescence
is a developmental phase. Your adolescent still requires
your responsive love and affection, and she will not be
helped to grow up by your "tough love" or disapproval.
Afterword
Smart Love: Your Companion on Your Child's journey to
Adulthood
In most areas of our lives we make momentous decisions
only after much deliberation, and even then we may
experiment a bit to make sure we have chosen the correct
path. Parents, however, are faced every day with a
multitude of vital decisions that come thick and fast.
Because parents can't see the final result of their
choices until their children have reached adulthood,
they find it difficult to evaluate the quality of their
responses and they worry about whether they are making
the right choices. Some examples of the dilemmas parents
face on a daily basis are: Do we feed our baby whenever
she wants or put her on a schedule? Do we make our
toddler share and stop her from grabbing, or do we let
her outgrow these tendencies on her own? Do we
discipline our child when she is disobedient or
destructive, or is there a kinder method to guide her?
Do we impose consequences on children who don't do their
homework or pick up their room, or do we help them do
chores and homework? Should we respond to the difficult
adolescent with tough love or tender love?
We wrote Smart Love to help you with the thousand and
one decisions you have to make as parents. Because smart
love principles remain the same whether you are
parenting a newborn or an adolescent, Smart Love can be
your companion and helpmate at every step on your
child's journey to adulthood.
The choices parents make are particularly tough at
moments when their child is difficult or unhappy and,
especially, if their child is chronically difficult or
unhappy. If you have a problematic child of any age, we
have also written this book for you. By following smart
love principles you can help your child recapture her
birthright of inner happiness.
By using the smart love guidelines you can provide your
child with a reliable, enduring core happiness that is
unwavering even in the face of life's unavoidable
disappointments and misfortunes. We emphasize that this
accomplishment is made possible by establishing a
pleasurable relationship and not by frustrating your
child's needs or depriving her of your attention. Your
child's inner well-being rests on her certain knowledge
that she has caused you to love caring for her. Of all
the gifts you can give your child, this is the most
important, because it is the foundation of all happiness
and goodness and the shield against self-caused
unhappiness.
If you choose to use the principles of smart love, you
will have more confidence that you know what to do every
day and every year to sustain and nurture your child's
emotional well-being. One reason that you can rely on
smart love to guide your daily decisions about your
child is that smart love considers childhood from your
child's point of view. In fact the entire smart love
approach is built on this unique perspective. Smart love
establishes a more realistic, less pressured timetable
for your child's emotional development; introduces you
to new developmental milestones and shows you how to
help your child reach them; and offers you a way to
shield your child from the consequences of her
immaturity without resorting to permissiveness,
disciplinary measures, or rewards--all of which are
counterproductive. With the help of smart love
guidelines, you can raise a successful, well-regulated,
and, most important, a truly happy child while loving
and enjoying her to your heart's content.